bakerstreet | Bad boy

The Good / Bad Pairing Meme

Attraction is a strange beast. It's hard to pinpoint just why you may want to shag that particular person...or, even worse, why you're in love with them! And can't that be bad enough when the two of you are, but what about when you're completely different? Or maybe you're not even on the side! You're a superhero (or at least on the side of good), he or she's a super villain... How would your relationship pan out if things were like that?

Okay, it may not be as dramatic as that. You two could just be the "good" guy/girl in school, the goody two shoes, who's fallen in love with the "bad" boy/girl, leather jacket and all. Whatever the case may be, things won't be easy.

How To Play
- Comment with your character, putting the standard information somewhere in it. You also may want to specify your preferences or where your character would fall for each set of prompts. Some characters may be different things for each: ie, someone like Dean Winchester would probably be a traditional "bad boy" in the first sit, but a hero in the second.
- Tag others! Feel free to use the RNG. Roll twice. First number chooses the prompt set, second the prompt number.
- Have fun and be respectful to others.

1) Every Good Girl Loves a Bad Boy
1. Summer Lovin', Happened So Fast: One of you is straight laced, while the other walks on the wild side (interpret that as loosely as you'd like). Somehow, though, you've come together.
2. Daddy Don't Approve: Your friends or family don't like your partner.
3. Be My Lover but Don't Be My Friend: You're just in it for the sex.
4. Uptown Girl: There's more than just "good" and "bad" at play, here; there's also class differences.
5. Ashamed to Be Seen: You care about this person, but you're rep's more important.
6. Love 'Em and Leave 'Em: You thought you were important, but your lover's just left you by the wayside for some reason.
7. Against All Odds: Somehow, you're standing up to all the naysayers, and you've lasted.
8. WILDCARD

2) Heroes and Villains
1. Love or Hate at First Sight: Pretty self explanatory. This baddie/good guy is a little different than the rest.
2. Got to Have You: The good party's been kidnapped by the bad, for some reason. Is it love, lust, annoyance? Who knows?
3. Stockholm Syndrome: You're the one who's been kidnapped or hurt, but you're falling in lovelust with your captor.
4. Reverse Stockholm Syndrome: You're the kidnapper, but you're falling in love/lust with your charge.
5. Unrequited Love: One of you cares for the other, but it's not returned.
6. Purification: Through the power of love, the bad guy has been won over and changed affiliations!
7. Corruption: Through the power of lust and manipulation, the good guy has fallen in order to be with the other person.
8. The BatCat Scenario: You've both decided to stay on your own sides, but whenever you meet, there's enough UST to power a small city.
9. Bad End: One or both of you have been killed or hurt by your affair.
10. WILDCARD

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

((bad, and not particularly friendly or tender without serious long-term development so he's not a good option for "one soft spot" type pairings. that said, he's got no real megalomania or power hunger issues so he's a "constantly causing damage everywhere he goes because his ability to care got broken" villain rather than an "i will rule you and everyone with an iron fist because i wanna" villain.))

[Since he's all over the place in various realities/timelines he can be your Angel or your Devil XD All versions available.]

( certified Good Boy™ and hero type. interested in 1-6, 1-7, 2-1, 2-5, 2-8 ! )

[ Can do either. ]

[Rico can be very charming and everything you would want at first, but he's a big, big liar and more prone to revealing the depths of his real self as time goes on. Liable to get obsessed with someone, then soon lose interest for someone shinier. Here's his info and permissions/warnings.

Interested in exploring hero and villain dynamics or judge/citizen in his canon setting, but he can be AU'd into other settings fairly easily as well. Open to cross canon/medium! Would prefer jumping right into assumed cr for this.

Anyway, things that could be interesting to explore:
- IDENTITY SHENANIGANS. 'ummm my loving boyfriend has been acting slightly off this week but I didn't think it would be horrible supervillain crimes wtf'
- Rico showing some hints of bad boy just enough to be exciting edgy, only to draw you in and hit you with the 'oh shit, this boy does MURDERS' stick.
- he's a good fit for corruption tropes, if you need your nice type to form a bad habit or relationship with an unfortunately attractive and deep-voiced villain against good advice.
- some good old-fashioned nemesis hatefucking. Might be open to dubcon situations, but that depends and let's discuss first.
- doting bf buys you lots of presents and treats you to some very nice things and experiences. Problem is, it's all bought with dirty money. why does this necklace have blood on it? where did you get this highly experimental prototype? did you set the other bad guy who's been bothering me on fire? wh-]

[ Depends on whose shoulder she's on. She's better than some, worse than others. Open to options, AUs, Assumed CR, pretty much anything. ]

Edited 2023-08-22 06:19 (UTC)

( f/m 25+ or previous cr. sam's been written off by a lot of people as 'bad,' and she definitely has her bad moments but she wants to be good. she's trying so hard and fighting with herself to be good. so... could go either way. )

Bad boy

Natsuo Todoroki (villain au) | MHA

Kabal | Mortal Kombat | OTA

Paul Lahote | Twilight

ryuji sakamoto | persona 5 royal

Chrissy Cunningham | Stranger Things

Lancelot du Lac | Fandom Fate OC | ota

Yamaguchi Tadashi | Haikyuu!! | m/m

Nagisa Hazuki ( Free! )

Gorou 🐾 Genshin Impact 🐾 OTA

Yuma Tsukumo ( Yu-Gi-Oh! Zexal ) m/m

Rico Dredd | Judge Dredd | 18+

Sadie Adler | Red Dead Redemption 2 : M/F for ship. OTA for gen

sam carpenter 🔪 scream