Tea or coffee? Swords or guns?

[mcmemeface]

Would You Rather...?

How to Play
One person asks "Would you rather...?" followed by two options. They can range from mundane to outrageously horrific: be a cat OR be a dog, save starving children in Africa OR have a real working lightsaber, etc. Others decide which they would choose of the two given options. Friendships are created or destroyed.



The Rules
1. Comment with your character with a "Would you rather...?" starter.
2. Respond to other characters with your character's choice out of two (probably horrible) choices.
3. DISCUSS.


Credit to cherrytrees
Need some ideas? Here's a site.

Comments

Matt Murdock | MCU | OTA

[thedevilsworkisneverdone]

For those with both on their phones...

Would you rather someone see all the photos in your phone or read all your text messages?

[attackpatternbattista]

Oh, dear. That's a difficult one.

Of the two, the photos are probably the less scandalous and would cause the least problems.

shinzaki toya | glass heart

[chromebeat]

Would you rather lose your eyesight or your hearing?

[bringmethestarlight]

Eyesight. I don't think I could live without hearing music.

Medjed | Egyptian mythology | ota

[gotlegs]

Would you rather have control over the manner of your death or the length of your life?

[ ooc: info & permissions ]

[unironically]

What does the length of a life matter, if your death ends up shameful? The former.

Ari Tayrey | Original | OTA

[astrogator]

Would you rather get stranded on an ice planet or a desert planet?

[desertflower]

Desert, no questions.

Harley Quinn | DCEU

[acrobatshit]

Would you rather know you're insane and refuse to take meds for it, or know you're sane and everyone else thinks you're bonkers?

[backendbat]

Well I hate the thought of other people thinking I'm crazier than usual....Probably would rather know I'm insane.

Peter Parker | TASM/MCU | ota

[stupidbutgood]

Would you rather eat milk chocolate or white chocolate or dark chocolate?

[thedevilsworkisneverdone]

Tier ranking:
Milk chocolate
White chocolate
The basement of Hell
Dark chocolate

gorgo | fragments of sappho / original | ota

[unironically]

Would you rather possess nothing but the knowledge of the world's evils or live a life forever ignorant of what is wrong in the world?

[deusexmakie]

... I so very much yearn to be ignorant. If only I had the luxury of being a fool.

shane hollander | heated rivalry

[canadien]

Would you rather lose a sense or lose a limb?

[mysophobe]

I could live without my sense of smell. I'd rather keep all my limbs.

Mira | KPop Demon Hunters

[yeahthatsright]

Decent dessert every night, or one heavenly dessert every month?

[pluviosus]

I don't think I could limit dessert to once per month no matter how good it is.

renji abarai | bleach | ota

[bonecannon]

If someone you cared about could get a big leg up in the world, but it meant you may never see or talk to them again... would you let 'em go or ask 'em to stay?

[willmakeitworse]

.....that'd depend on what they want, wouldn't it?

I'd ask them that question to their face, then look at their reaction and act accordingly.

Lt. Col. John Sheppard | Stargate: Atlantis | OTA

[ferriswheelsandfootball]

Fly the Enterprise or the Millennium Falcon?

[brbs]

How about you fly to a party and pick up some girls, nerd?

( because only a nerd would waste a question on sci-fi movies. )

stu macher / scream

[brbs]

Kill or be killed? Which one?

( it's just a question! )

[amicustenebris]

Fairly obvious answer. Why ask?

Wei Wuxian | Mo Dao Zu Shi

[emperorssmile]

Would you rather have a jar of wine that never runs dry or have your favorite fruit tree bear fruit no matter the season?

[pink_is_back]

I'd rather have endless fruit all year long.

Ramie ✧ PSG

[discountdeity]

Would you rather live eternally in the lap of luxury in Heaven, or spend the remainder of your miserable days with the vermin of the Underworld?

[ He knows most of you are going to Hell. ]

[nuraridouman]

Taking over the Underworld seems like an entertaining idea. Can't be much worse than trying to teach youkai, either.

But most importantly...

caroline weston | oc

[sweetaspie]

Do something illegal and "just", or legal and fucked up?

If that's too heavy, we'll do fight "one horse-sized duck" or "ten duck sized horses".

[pink_is_back]

If it does good for others, and is just, as you say, then I wouldn't care if it was illegal.

Chishiya Shuntaro. Alice in Borderland. OTA

[surgicalcynicism]

Would you rather feel everything a little too much, or feel nothing at all?

[ricochetingbullets]

Considering I've done both, feel nothing at all. Hands down.

dean winchester (demon) | spn

[returnofthemark]

Metallica or Megadeth?

[fellfurthest]

Metallica.

Benjamin "Dex" Poindexter | MCU

[ricochetingbullets]

Would you rather live in a time of peace but be completely alone or live in a time of war but be surrounded by people who care about you?

[mikoshi]

Sweet ain't so sweet without the sour. Second one.

Yamato Endo | Wind Breaker | ota

[willmakeitworse]

Would you rather have a "purpose" or "warmth"?

Principal/Douman Ashiya | A Terrified Teacher At Ghoul School! | ota

[nuraridouman]

Would you rather have a pay cut or entertaining physical torture?

[galacticambition]

Do I get to torture someone?

[The question is very important, okay?]

kaveh / genshin impact

[freeload]

Would you rather have a vivid imagination or a photographic memory?

[fellfurthest]

[BITTER LAUGH.] I wasn't aware you ever could have one without the other.

anaxagoras / hsr

[particular]

Would you rather be reviled for your true self, or beloved for a charade?

[fellfurthest]

The first one.

Lucifer Morningstar | Obey Me | OTA

[fellfurthest]

Coffee or tea?

[discountdeity]

Tea is the most refined answer. Coffee is for mindless plebs enslaved by the system.

Vivienne Beaulieu | OC | ota

[necromanager]

Would you rather hibernate through winter or summer?

[desertflower]

Winter. I'm not well-suited for cold.

Arid | The Fall | OTA

[inperspective]

Would you choose to carry out a dangerous task yourself, or delegate it to someone else?

[doublecrowned]

Were I best suited to the task, I would carry it out myself.